Confluence Latest : Confluence 4 Editor - Customer Feedback

FAQs

Commonly brought up comments which may be of use to others who are following this page

QuestionAnswer
Is there a 'Confluence 4 for Wiki Markup users' guide available?Yes, please see Confluence 4 Editor - What's Changed for Wiki Markup Users. If you have anything you'd like to see added to that page, please leave a comment there.
How can I edit the source / storage format of a page in Confluence or in an external editor.You can download the Source Editor, a free plugin maintained by Atlassian and available here.
I have a script that generates Wiki Markup, can I still insert it into a page?Yes. You can use the Insert Wiki Markup Dialog, just choose 'Insert' then 'Wiki Markup' or use the shortcut "command/ctl + shift + D"
I have a script that generates Wiki Markup and writes it to a Confluence page using the API, can I still do this?Yes. You can still send Wiki markup to the API which will convert it to the new source format and save. See this Answers discussion for more.
I have a script that consumed Wiki Markup from Confluence, do I need to re-write it?Yes. Wiki Markup is no longer available as an output from Confluence. Unfortunately this means you will need to re-write any scripts which consumed Wiki Markup from Confluence (often via the API as an example) to instead read the new XML based Storage Format.
I take notes in meetings etc offline in a text editor, formatted with Wiki markup then add them to a page later, how can I do this now?Take your notes as before then insert them into a page using the Insert Wiki Markup Dialog, just choose 'Insert' then 'Wiki Markup' or use the shortcut "command(or ctrl)+shift+D"
How can I move the cursor outside a Macro (eg: a {code} or {column} macro) without using the mouse?You can just press the 'down' arrow until the cursor moves out of the macro and back onto the page.
A macro I wrote that worked in 3.x no longer works for Confluence 4See Upgrading and Migrating an Existing Confluence Macro to 4.0
Enter/Return gives me a new paragraph, how do I insert just a line break?Press Shift+Enter
How can I quickly turn already entered text into a linkYou can highlight the string you want to convert, press [ and wait until the autocomplete menu appears then select from the available options to Search for a page with the title of that text, insert a web link with that text as the clickable link or to insert a link to create a page with that title.
A short "how-to" from Shannon Greywalker for doing unbalanced tables, tables within tables, etc. in the new 4.x editor.Available here.
Why not make wiki-markup editor on top of XHTML storage? Just some engine, which would convert XHTML to wiki-markup and back on save.

Wiki markup can only represent a subset of what can be represented in XHTML. A wiki to XHTML conversion would be lossy meaning that when a 'wiki preferring' author made changes to the page of an 'xhtml preferring' author they would mangle (to some degree) the original author's page.

This is a reverse of the round-tripping bugs that used to be encountered when the storage was wiki but the editor was HTML.

One fairly typical example would be the case of merged table cells. Confluence Wiki markup cannot represent merged cells, whereas XHTML (and so therefore Confluence storage format) can.

I want to force something to stay as Wiki Markup on a page, not be converted.You can use Bob Swift's Confluence Wiki Plugin, details here.
Is there a way to search across the instance for where a macro is used in a page?You can do this with the use of the Confluence Macro Indexer plugin. Details on it's use are available here.

External Resources

Contributors to this page have kindly collated the following useful references which may assist anyone transitioning from Wiki Markup to the new Editor

  • A short "how-to" from Shannon Greywalker for doing unbalanced tables, tables within tables, etc. in the new 4.x editor is Available here.
  • Advanced tips on the Confluence 4 editor, wiki markup and the XML storage format by Graham Hannington are available here: Advanced Confluence Tips. These include information about: 
    • Wikifier, a tool for converting Confluence XML to wiki markup, and for converting Confluence rich text to wiki markup. 
    • A Greasemonkey script for The Wiki markup toolbar button which selects the page contents and opens it in the Insert Wiki Markup Dialog for editing.


Bugs / Improvement / New Feature Requests

If you have feedback on a bug, a task you now find harder or are unable to do in the new editor then please leave a comment below and we'll incorporate it into this page (and remove the comment afterwards). Please note that these are usually only updated once completely fixed, we track progress separately on an internal queue.

Resolved

Click here to expand...

JIRA Issues (118 issues)

Type Key Summary Resolution
Bug CONF-25268 Autoformat and certain autocomplete functions do not work when preceded by a parenthesis Fixed
Bug CONF-23575 Links to filesystem are lost after upgrade to Confluence 4.x or upon saving the page in the new editor Fixed
Bug CONF-27945 Autoconvert of JIRA filter URLs does not work with JIRA 5.2 Fixed
Improvement CONF-23022 Allow to set default location for newly added pages Fixed
Improvement CONF-23884 Can't create page based on template through link Fixed
Bug CONF-26704 Making tables sortable Fixed
Improvement CONF-23547 Allow users to specify alt and title for images in the WYSIWYG editor Fixed
Improvement CONF-24665 Add ability to create links using non-standard protocols Fixed
Bug CONF-26584 Click an image, or macro placeholder can sometimes activate drag and drop behaviour. Fixed
Bug CONF-27738 PDF icon doesn't show up in link browser / attachments screen Fixed
Bug CONF-24624 Links to anchors on other pages in Confluence 4.0+ cannot be edited. Fixed
Bug CONF-23279 Multi-byte characters in macro placeholder aren't displayed at all. Fixed
Bug CONF-25937 Editing an existing link produces a strange behavior in IE8 Fixed
Task CONF-24168 Remove Google Gears references Fixed
Bug CONF-23633 Actions doeditpage,domovepage,docreatepage do not require XSRF token Fixed
Bug CONF-27785 No 'spade' in symbols dialog Fixed
Bug CONF-23829 Mouse cursor is misplaced after bullet list indentation Fixed
Bug CONF-23828 Copy and paste a word somewhere in between the line makes the mouse cursor jumped to the end of line after hitting Backspace button Fixed
Bug CONF-23827 Mouse cursor jumped to the end of line after inserting the auto formatting of asterisk or dash button in Firefox 8 Fixed
Bug CONF-23782 Extra spaces are inserted when macro placeholders are inserted Fixed
Bug CONF-27750 Autoconvert cuts out anchor components from anchor links Fixed
Bug CONF-25365 Shift+enter in a list item with a panel macro on the page whole page if you are scrolled Fixed
Bug CONF-26089 On a long page, hitting shift+enter on Chrome will jump your current line to the top of the viewport Fixed
Bug CONF-27749 Hitting Shift+enter in a long, scrolled table jumps the browser down to the current cursor position Fixed
Bug CONF-27748 image resizing busted? Fixed
Bug CONF-27747 Multiple lines a table heading are not rendered as bold. Fixed
Bug CONF-27746 The "Learn more about templates" link is hard coded and wrong. Change to use help-paths.properties. Check for others. Fixed
Bug CONF-27745 Tablesort icons are repeating incorrectly in tasklist, contentbylabel, RSVP and attachments macros Fixed
Bug CONF-27744 When typing a comment quickly, always seem to be a blank line above Fixed
Bug CONF-27743 Can you make it so that undo in Confluence doesn't jump me to the top of the editor? Fixed
Bug CONF-27741 Able to delete/destroy page layout within the editor Fixed
Bug CONF-27736 Opening a link to an undefined page loads a 404 Fixed
Bug CONF-27735 Unable to break out of a numbered sublist Fixed
Bug CONF-27734 Layout icon incorrect: 50:50 has 66:33 icon instead Fixed
Improvement CONF-27080 Make table cell colour buttons more intuitive Fixed
Bug CONF-25145 Heading loses formatting when preceding newline is deleted Fixed
Bug CONF-27365 Add a new icon for disabling cell highlight - not white Fixed
Bug CONF-26396 Editor buttons disabled when invalid macro used Fixed
Bug CONF-27226 Copy-paste data-uri based images works in edit mode, fails on save Fixed
Bug CONF-24286 En dash in heading title breaks anchor links Fixed
Improvement CONF-26698 Separate row/column highlight from the new background colouring Fixed
Bug CONF-21091 Add Image in WYSIWYG isn't completely translated to French Fixed
Bug CONF-27366 Breadcrumbs do not expand properly when doing a preview during page creation Fixed
Bug CONF-27363 Cannot change a table row from header to normal Fixed
Bug CONF-27364 Highlight row/column doesn't work if whole row/column is selected Fixed
Bug CONF-27367 Editing table with cells with non-white background looses any previous background color set Fixed
New Feature CONF-24201 Ability to nest Expand macros Fixed
Bug CONF-23410 Can't break out of a list item after shift+enter Fixed
Improvement CONF-21788 Link updater changes last modifier of linking page Fixed
Bug CONF-26348 Find & Replace - Cmd+F should focus find input if previous find session aborted Fixed
New Feature CONF-27010 Draggable images and macros Fixed
Improvement CONF-24563 Cannot drag and drop within the new editor Fixed
Bug CONF-26971 View file macro does not detect an office file attached during editing (through insert link/attachment) straight away Fixed
Bug CONF-24488 Table entered via Wiki Markup Dialog Box wraps cells in p tags. Fixed
Bug CONF-25994 cut paste of paragraph + bullets loses the paragraph content Fixed
Improvement CONF-26493 Autoconvert for HR after space not just enter Fixed
Improvement CONF-11744 Creating a template using the rich text editor Fixed
Bug CONF-25062 Making lists out of paragraph text differs from plain text to list context. Fixed
New Feature CONF-2493 Sortable Tables Fixed
Bug CONF-26497 Sorting little triangle on top of table columns is drawn opposite than expected Fixed
Bug CONF-26496 When I add a linefeed to a table header, it unbolds and becomes bottom-aligned... Fixed
Bug CONF-26502 it is too easy to drop an object in the wrong place and lose it Fixed
Bug CONF-26500 dragging something from one th to another th will highlight the source th Fixed
Bug CONF-26504 Unable to drag image across to neighbouring cell (IE9) Fixed
Bug CONF-26503 Dragging content into body macro causes placeholder to shake Fixed
Bug CONF-26501 Dragging content towards the bottom of a page causes editor to jump Fixed
Bug CONF-26226 The table drop-down is positioned over the button instead of beneath it using the quick comment editor Fixed
Bug CONF-25406 Centering a paragraph loses image effect Fixed
Bug CONF-24567 Copy & paste image data into RTE no longer working in Firefox 10 Fixed
Bug CONF-24482 Moving the cursor down in a table and pasting freezes the editor. Fixed
Bug CONF-24095 Safari 5 support broken in new editor: cut and paste inside macro blocks is unusable Fixed
Bug CONF-23923 Backspace key can cause unexpected embedded macros to appear on Safari Fixed
Bug CONF-26299 Pressing Escape in Wiki Markup Dialog breaks future usages in editing session Fixed
Bug CONF-26488 Chrome + Inline Tasks: Enter+Enter creates a <div/> Fixed
Bug CONF-26019 Editor freezes when moving down with cursor and pasting status macro Fixed
Bug CONF-25108 Pasting HTML tags into a Confluence table can cause the editor to lock up Fixed
New Feature CONF-6482 Custom background colour for rows or cells in table Fixed
New Feature CONF-23914 Source Editor Plugin - Edit XHTML Fixed
Bug CONF-26030 Pasting code into a code block in Confluence looses existing formatting of the code Fixed
Bug CONF-25670 Either Jira or jira should autoformat to JIRA Fixed
Bug CONF-25373 Selecting multiple fields in table and utilizing shortcut for bold causes row shift Fixed
Bug CONF-25397 Un-indenting a non-indented paragraph scrolls to top of page (Chrome) Fixed
Bug CONF-25369 Creating list items in the same table cell with a paragraph in between renders with different indentation padding Fixed
Bug CONF-25418 Both Toolbar buttons are Active when nesting a UL inside an OL or vice-versa Fixed
Bug CONF-23281 Highlight panel text look mis-aligned with icon when there is no title. Fixed
Bug CONF-23809 Mention user name links are occasionally replaced by the page title Fixed
Bug CONF-24571 Save, Preview, Cancel Button Grey Out When Create JIRA Issue Fixed
Bug CONF-25226 DEL at the end of the numbered line doesn't delete the line break Fixed
Bug CONF-25201 Font sizes in the Popular Labels Macro Heatmap are being overridden when placed in the footer section of a page layout Fixed
Bug CONF-23497 Bullet points are not aligned with the text in Safari/Chrome Fixed
Improvement CONF-4042 Search/Replace support in WYSIWYG Editor Fixed
New Feature CONF-24038 Allow quick insertion of macros, links and embedded content using autoformat Fixed
Bug CONF-24709 Entered text is lost in Firefox after previewing, entering text and saving Fixed
Bug CONF-24017 Link Text not editable when editing a link to an attachment Fixed
Bug CONF-24066 Copying and pasting plain text containing brackets into a table cell freezes the editor Fixed
Improvement CONF-23842 Copying and pasting list items into an existing list Fixed
Bug CONF-25063 Delete and backspace do the wrong thing in lists with macros Fixed
Bug CONF-25030 No spacing between page first paragraph and table Fixed
Bug CONF-23844 More weirdness with nested bullets Fixed
Bug CONF-23234 up and down arrow keys should navigate the cursor to the cell above/below in the table Fixed
Bug CONF-23380 Can't see bottom of some pages in editor Fixed
Bug CONF-23566 Copying and pasting white space inside the code macro does not work (right click also causes the selection to collapse undesirably) Fixed
Bug CONF-24330 Confluence editor does not preserve layout when pasting tab characters Fixed
Bug CONF-23691 Selecting the whole contents of a code macro and pasting text into it removes the placeholder in webkit Fixed
Bug CONF-23544 default macro parameter not accessible within EditorImagePlaceholder#getImagePlaceholder Fixed
New Feature CONF-24244 Cut, Paste Table row cant be performed to put a row at the buttom. Fixed
Improvement CONF-23408 Ability for users to copy and paste tables and multiple rows and cells Fixed
Bug CONF-24097 Trying to delete bullets from editor results in unselectable hanging bullet Fixed
Bug CONF-23578 Cannot delete list item that is before a nested list item in webkit Fixed
Bug CONF-24058 error when you copy in to the table a text containing the characters '«' or '»' (Windows (CP-1251): '«' - 171 '»' - 187) Fixed
Bug CONF-24096 crossing out of text does not work Fixed
Bug CONF-18922 if the last content on a page is a table row, positioning the cursor after it and presing enter/return in the RTE causes a new line to be created at the top of the page not the end Fixed
Bug CONF-23456 Copy pasting text into the new editor causes the page to "jump" to the end of the pasted text rather than staying put Fixed
Bug CONF-23483 Pasting email links containing upper-case (capital) letters does not autoformat correctly Fixed
Bug CONF-23810 ALT + CTRL + S inserts an illegal control character in safari that prevents the page from being saved Fixed
Bug CONF-23457 Certain combinations of keypresses causes the editor to lose focus in Chrome Fixed
Bug CONF-23701 After creating link in editor the backspace removes paragraph text after the cursor in editor 4.0.3 Fixed
Bug CONF-23551 Multi-byte characters aren't displayed correctly in Code Block Macro. Fixed

Open

Too add your issue, please raise a ticket in the CONF Project using the Component 'Editing' and specify the Affects Version. For bugs, please include your OS and Browser details.

Click here to expand...

Please note that while JIRA issues have been raised for all these comments, I don't want to set unreasonable expectations so just be aware that being in this list is not a guarantee of something being implemented. As always our Implementation of New Features Policy and Bug Fixing Policy apply.

Bugs (200 issues)

Key Summary Status
CONF-28627 Page Not Found when trying to edit an existing page New
CONF-28605 What did you change comment does not get saved when using German language New
CONF-28577 Drafts do not save when adding or editing a page unless you close the tab or window and click "Leave this Page" Awaiting Quality Review
CONF-28561 Confluence Page Layout goes FUBAR New
CONF-28511 Weird Table creation Issue with IE 8 Open
CONF-28484 Link in Confluence pages cannot be edited in IE9 & IE 10 when Page Layout is in used Technical Review
CONF-28457 When creating a page from a template with labels, the labels dialog in the editor will not show the labels from the template Open
CONF-28391 Font size distorted under a macro Open
CONF-28389 colouring the cell of table in chrome Needs Verification
CONF-28381 the iframe#wysiwygTextarea_ifr needs min-height set New
CONF-28362 Property 'scrollTo' of object [object global] is not a function New
CONF-28353 Unable to edit a link once it has been created inside a panel New
CONF-28352 Editor: cursor jumps to wrong place after inserting macros New
CONF-28344 Setting a line to h1 in a section causes image to dissapear Open
CONF-28343 Forward delete broken in bullet lists Open
CONF-28341 The editor notifications for things like find/replace wrapping no longer appear Open
CONF-28335 Can't edit pages when using piwik analytics code Open
CONF-28307 Unable to add or edit the description of templates Open
CONF-28206 Scroll Bar Disappears in Edit Mode Open
CONF-28180 Attachements with "+" character makes image effects run infinite New
CONF-28117 Unable to select using mouse on heading and table together inside a macro Needs Verification
CONF-28098 Batch.css changed to add a background color to confluenceTd Open
CONF-28083 Mult-byte characters aren't displayed in the gadget placeholder in editor New
CONF-28077 Inserting a conflunce attache as an external image, then making it a thumbnail stays a thumbnail when clicking on it. Open
CONF-28035 Insert link dialog fails with [] characters in link Open
CONF-28022 Image links not working with Page Layouts in Firefox Open
CONF-28017 Creating a macro (note, tip, etc) within a list with a font effect on, then disabling the effect in the macro box causes duplicates that macro. Open
CONF-28008 Initial cursor position in the Insert Image dialog is wrong Open
CONF-27980 Images can't be resized to >900px Open
CONF-27962 Content of page in preview mode is not able to be copied using CTRL + C Open
CONF-27957 Emoticons are lost on save when inside a link Open
CONF-27947 Clicking on an aligned image is no longer reflected in the left|center|right align Open
CONF-27910 Entering new line before a table will returns cursor back to top of editor Open
CONF-27858 Insert wiki markup in a template causes wiki markup conversion errors New
CONF-27846 Inserting Wiki to Create Link to Page With Full URL Path Fails Open
CONF-27814 Hyphen in a date causes confluence to turn the date into a hyperlink Open
CONF-27800 Cut and Paste in Table (IE9) Open
CONF-27796 Quick Comment Loader Freezes Safari Awaiting Quality Review
CONF-27754 Copying and pasting a link to a Confluence page results in a web URL link instead of a space/page link Open
CONF-27742 Can insert new lines above page layout Open
CONF-27707 If the comment editor is open (but not in focus) 'e' shortcut jumps to it instead of editing page New
CONF-27696 Heading loses formatting when preceding newline is deleted New
CONF-27682 Formatting is lost when a line break is used in Expand Macro New
CONF-27625 Can't delete macroplaceholder and surrounding text when both are selected (IE9) Open
CONF-27619 Editor freezes upon pasting rendered CSS Open
CONF-27615 Changing a tables cell colors, while having text selected reverts the cells to white Open
CONF-27579 Copy and paste table into a cell New
CONF-27539 IE9, Property Panel disappears when using "Page Layouts" New
CONF-27499 Missing blank when using @mention inside a list-item, with an indented list item following Open
CONF-27491 Automatic draft saving stops working when jira-connector com.atlassian.confluence.plugins.jira.jira-connector plugin is disabled Open
CONF-27472 NumberFormatException When Cancelling Page Edits Open
CONF-27469 Attachment link failed to update correctly in IE8 Open
CONF-27457 balsamic mock is positioned incorrectly on a page template Open
CONF-27437 When unlinking a link in an <li>, the nolink span will now wrongly propagate to subsequent list items New
CONF-27417 Deleting a row from a table that has merged cells will mess up the table New
CONF-27390 Storage format shows incorrectly in IE Open
CONF-27387 title attribute in new editor doesn't support scandinavian characters Open
CONF-27225 Definition lists confuse the editor in Firefox Open
CONF-27140 Italics and bulleted lists in Chrome causes formatting issues Open
CONF-27114 Select All - Copy -> Paste will not paste images but refer to source images. New
CONF-27104 Every cell in a table is a heading and the associated controls don't work New
CONF-27079 Awesome paste no longer works for skitch embeds because the URL has changed to Evernote Open
CONF-27036 Creating a Web Link to a URL that contains [] characters results in <a rel="nofollow"></a> New
CONF-27014 Sorting table does not work if column contains empty cells Open
CONF-26945 option to remove indentation from tasks is not enabled (outdent) New
CONF-26920 Bottom bar of editor disappears when editing table in IE if jira connector plugin is disabled Open
CONF-26918 Formatting table cells: allow shading, heading styles instead of simply the "highlight" function. New
CONF-26822 Copy/paste of JIRA issue links into editor looks like it works when it doesn't Open
CONF-26783 Tables do not align with images in Easy Reader theme Open
CONF-26754 Resuming page edit with IE8 causes the "What did you change?" comment to be added Open
CONF-26748 Text formatting misbehave once Shift+Enter is used. Open
CONF-26741 Underlined texts in a page from an imported Word doc results in a strange behavior in Firefox Open
CONF-26731 Attachment link properties panel doesn't appear in the editor when the link appears broken or greyed out in the page due to missing attachment or other reason Open
CONF-26710 Applying text colour to all text via Ctrl + A does not apply the colour to some of the list items Open
CONF-26690 Create Page action with provided labelString parameter does not show labels in Label dialog Open
CONF-26678 Page title in Edit Link dialog is encoded. Open
CONF-26668 Adding row to tables with many columns generates 'script unresponsive' error in IE8 Open
CONF-26639 Weird behaviour on medium size image on Confluence 4.3 editor using Chrome in Windows 7 Open
CONF-26629 Quote block disappears after few quote blocks are created in IE8 Open
CONF-26622 Double click for Macro properties doesn't work for nested macros Open
CONF-26596 Using color macro inside headings in Wiki Markup results in double headings Open
CONF-26576 Editor: keyboard navigation is broken with large code blocks Open
CONF-26574 The number of attachement in page edit mode is wrong, it is summing all the version of the attachments Open
CONF-26556 Mention autocomplete breaks subsequent editor formatting Open
CONF-26537 Line breaks are deleted if <div> elements are used Open
CONF-26533 Table column Sorting doesnt detect date text Open
CONF-26530 Protocol of external link changes from "http" to "https" on save Open
CONF-26482 Pressing command-z to undo often undoes more than the last actions Open
CONF-26475 when clicking on a picture to edit it it jumps to a lower position Open
CONF-26453 selected image doesn't show alignment state Open
CONF-26445 Deleting text with different foreground colours removes the foreground colour Open
CONF-26444 Unable to insert links Open
CONF-26393 Unable to insert horizontal rule between two body macros Open
CONF-26392 Pasting screenshots in a table places the cursor out of the table Open
CONF-26389 Editor creates a link with an URL of its own preference, not the one user typed in to create Open
CONF-26388 Editor: can not edit a link, referencing the same page Open
CONF-26387 Advanced link edit starts with a blank field Open
CONF-26380 Editor issues - misalignment of cursor in IE9 browser Open
CONF-26372 Drop down boxes appearing blank in some people's search and edit functions Needs Verification
CONF-26326 Macros entered with wikimarkup don't preserve parameter values. Open
CONF-26323 Heading autoformatting does not work properly if followed by bullets in IE8 Open
CONF-26307 Table height in edit mode is too low after adding a Status Macro in IE 8 Open
CONF-26267 Adding a new row at the bottom of a table with a lot of rows causes firefox/javascript hang issue Open
CONF-26259 callto link works in preview but not after save Open
CONF-26223 Attempting to select contents of first table cell causes text to jump out of table (Safari) Open
CONF-26215 Cannot link to space with a custom logo set Open
CONF-26198 Table column sorting fails when the column contains emoteicon only Open
CONF-26192 Adding internal link on a status macro renders to a simple link Open
CONF-26185 command-left arrow goes back while in the editor Open
CONF-26178 Indent function doesn't work as expected when indenting tables Open
CONF-26172 Extra character of space is inserted into empty table cells editing a page in IE9 Open
CONF-26166 Entering "\\" in a link makes it uneditable Open
CONF-26152 Safari - backspace multiple lines in Info/Warning macro nests another macro Open
CONF-26151 Safari - Copying text from a Info/Warning macro copies the entire macro and text. Open
CONF-26146 Attachments being named wrong on IE8 Open
CONF-26145 miscoloured words in PDF export text font rendering Open
CONF-26118 Editing status macro multiple times increases memory usage of IE8 dramatically Open
CONF-26102 * sign (%2A) not working in web links and will break wiki markup Open
CONF-26086 Strikethrough format uses incorrect XHTML when migrated from wiki markup Open
CONF-26042 Cannot use an emoticon as a link Open
CONF-26033 Selecting an image, emoticons, and template variables via ctrl + shift + arrow selects adjacent word as well Open
CONF-26022 'Status' Macro does not urlencode text placed in title field. Open
CONF-26006 Custom HTML in the page head can hide bottom toolbar Open
CONF-25967 Creating external URL links containing curly brackets breaks the links Open
CONF-25962 Text styling wrong on page after View Office Word macro Needs Verification
CONF-25944 Failure when converting editor format to storage format. Open
CONF-25941 Copy&Paste an image into the RTE in Firefox does not show image Open
CONF-25928 Attachment link issues in IE8 Open
CONF-25926 Highlighting merged cells is buggy Open
CONF-25925 Cursor jumps to the top of the editor window when aligning text in Safari Open
CONF-25890 Cannot insert text before a link in a list Open
CONF-25882 After migration from 3.5.13 to 4.2.x and 4.3.x In page anchor displays with #anchorname instead of just anchorname Open
CONF-25880 Copy and Paste Row with Expand Macro or Note Macro Breaks Row Paste Open
CONF-25876 Loss of headings and no-format macros on page save Open
CONF-25837 Emoticon in front of link in table won't display Open
CONF-25836 Unable to indent bodied macros Open
CONF-25833 Clear Format not removing 'stuck' formatting Open
CONF-25820 Using "Add > Gliffy Diagram" (or UI Mockup) on Confluence page with more than one column adds the diagram above all the columns Open
CONF-25771 Copy/source mode in code macro using incorrect character for a space in Chrome Open
CONF-25770 Backspace to delete a bullet in a table cell leaves a <br> that cannot be removed Open
CONF-25767 HTML macro does not display wiki content properly when html tags used Open
CONF-25654 Large Tables cause Drag Select issue in Edit Mode with IE Open
CONF-25640 List item with only a panel macro does not display correctly... Open
CONF-25626 When you enter Japanese comment on Chrome, the first letter appears in alphabet Open
CONF-25624 Editor conflict screen is laid out badly, very hard to use Open
CONF-25616 When using Quote as font-style, the Italic button behaves reversed. Open
CONF-25614 Editor adds unneeded extra line below panel Open
CONF-25575 UI error when using the RichText Editor to insert a link with IE8. Open
CONF-25540 Code macro output content corrupted after partially parsing other code macro content from other page Needs Verification
CONF-25504 Thanks for fantastic WYSIWYG editing - press bold with no selected letters and wonder what happens Open
CONF-25452 Cannot edit link to new attachments while in the same editor session Open
CONF-25429 title not available when editing noformat macro Open
CONF-25419 Any inline autoformat (e.g. bold, italic, strikethrough) causes macros on the page to flash/blink. Block level (e.g. h1.) are ok. Open
CONF-25403 Pasting some HTML tags to editor crashes Chrome Open
CONF-25391 I can't paste a table inside an Expand macro, which is inside a table Open
CONF-25293 Odd formatting of content within column macros on a page. Open
CONF-25279 Some Keyboard Shortcut Screen & Tooltips on Mac incorrect for Safari & Chorme Open
CONF-25237 Impossible to merge table cells of the last row of a table (IE8) Open
CONF-25227 Text with colon incorrectly reconglised as a link Open
CONF-25225 Shift-Del doesn't work on Linux Open
CONF-25224 Cannot edit a link that refers to the current page Open
CONF-25206 Noformat Macro strips off leading whitespaces in IE8 Open
CONF-25203 Meta element forces the Editor in IE into using the IE 7 rendering engine, which breaks some plugins Open
CONF-25165 Multi-byte characters in status macro are not displayed on editor mode Open
CONF-25163 Editor Behavior with Backspace, and Find Open
CONF-25142 The shortcut 'e' does not switch the editor back from preview to edit in OnDemand. Open
CONF-25133 Confluence editor incorrectly capitalizes jira to JIRA Open
CONF-25111 Removing formatting from a bullet point moves the cursor to a new line Open
CONF-25104 Table toolbar does not go away after you remove a table Open
CONF-25093 Ctrl+A followed by Enter throws a JS error Open
CONF-25071 Chrome + Table: Column-Alignment not working Open
CONF-25064 Converting macros to list items fails and leaves behind weird formatting Open
CONF-25059 Both list type buttons highlighted in nested lists of mixed types Open
CONF-25057 Cut and Paste inside Lists is broken in several ways Open
CONF-25026 Command+Shift+N in Chrome broken Open
CONF-25006 Pasting specific content fails to save Open
CONF-24997 Crazy Confluence RTE bug with the 'Backspace' key - cursor jumps back more than one line and drags content along with it. Open
CONF-24968 Adding flat TOC above a Heading 1 results in TOC text becoming Heading 1 style Open
CONF-24958 Attachment link browser only shows first 50 attached files Open
CONF-24956 NBSP characters and h6. heading causing blank space Open
CONF-24943 Unexpected behaviour when indenting a bullet list Open
CONF-24940 Cannot highlight text, then drag and highlight text within a macro Open
CONF-24909 Shortcut Links in enumeration not working Open
CONF-24880 Mailto links doesn't allow special characters. Open
CONF-24876 Page with data-layout div but no layout cells Open
CONF-24867 Pasting from Chrome does not preserve tab/space characters Open
CONF-24864 Pasting text into Code Macro from a template erases the entire code block Open
CONF-24862 Page tree search macro not possible to center Open
CONF-24804 Safari 5 browser shortcuts override functionality in the editor Open
CONF-24803 Trying to insert macro parameters results in smilies sometimes Open
CONF-24769 Pasting a macro multiple times results in it nested Open
CONF-24767 Quick link macro broken for some page titles Open
CONF-24760 Copy and Paste problems with list and macro selections. Open
CONF-24756 Weird mouse selection behavior under Section macro Open
CONF-24753 Insert Link Containing Single Quote or Curly Braces Doesn't Work Open
CONF-24745 Selecting 'Preformatted' and then pasting a block of text into reverts to Paragraph style Open
CONF-24738 Selecting a column of a table no longer works in Confluence 4.0.5 or higher Open
CONF-24735 Pasting link, editing it with CTRL-K, changing link text, creates wrong end result Open
CONF-24696 Pasting large amounts of code into a code box causes the browser page to freeze Open
CONF-24689 Monospace autoformat doesn't work if your pasted text contains a link Open

Improvements/Feature Requests (59 issues)

Key Summary Status
CONF-28537 Be able to add labels via an inline control, not a dialog Open
CONF-28382 Show me who will be notified of my work inside the Editor Open
CONF-28313 As a plugin developer, I want to render the output of my macro in the editor Open
CONF-28229 Use Ctrl-Shift-V to 'paste unformatted' Open
CONF-28225 Have entire page scroll horizontally instead of just tables Open
CONF-28222 Middle mouse button paste (linux) fails Open
CONF-28221 Add 'ctrl-g' keyboard shortcut to in editor find and replace Open
CONF-28220 Confluence hogs my screen real estate New
CONF-28215 Indicate the JIRA instance name in the gadget browser (if there are multiple JIRA application links) Open
CONF-27979 Create an easy way to align a macro such as Table of Contents and have content wrap around it Open
CONF-27894 Provide ability to easily highlight text with color in WYSIWYG editor New
CONF-27880 Support justification / alignment on a selection of cells in a table New
CONF-27868 Numbered lists: continue from previous numbering or restart feature in Wiki editor New
CONF-27848 Add ability to set default sorting appearance for tables in Confluence New
CONF-27263 Allow case sensitive search (and replace) within wiki page Open
CONF-27051 Provide navigation in the editor while editing Open
CONF-27018 Heading is affecting further than what's being highlighted Open
CONF-26808 Respect different number formats when sorting tables Open
CONF-26655 Allow multiple page layouts in a single page / nested page layouts Open
CONF-26555 Cannot change a bullet list to a task list using only the keyboard Open
CONF-26473 Ctrl+e shortcut doesn't go to end-of-line in Confluence editor Open
CONF-26234 Fullscreen edit Open
CONF-26173 Rewrite links in macros inside paramaterised body macros Open
CONF-26165 Ability to create tables without borders Open
CONF-26083 Edit Default Space Content with the new editor Quality Review
CONF-26037 Macro Toolbar for changing Macro Options Open
CONF-25951 The new table sorting should also sort on emoticons (x), (/), (y), (n) Open
CONF-25894 Ctrl-E does not move to end of line in editor in OSX Open
CONF-25861 Return to Dashboard on Editor Cancel if you originated there Open
CONF-25753 Improve copy-paste experience between HipChat and Confluence for a conversation Open
CONF-25750 Make the notify watchers functionality of page edits more discreet Open
CONF-25533 Provide a nicer way to link to page anchors Open
CONF-25481 CTRL + 1, CTRL + 2, etc... should be a preference Open
CONF-25464 Improve editor vertical height usage, especially for smaller screens Open
CONF-25416 Upon pressing cancel while editing a page, wiki should ask if the user is sure about about cancelling the work Open
CONF-25376 Keyboard shortcut for Cancel while in the Editor Open
CONF-25331 Allow WidgetConnector to work with all youTube link types Open
CONF-25216 Allow macro parameters to be editable by KB shortcuts Open
CONF-25190 Add Regular Expression support to editor search & replace Open
CONF-25181 Copy and paste confluence table from MacOS Firefox 11 into MacOS Lion Mail app loses important formatting Open
CONF-24937 Image parameters that used to exist in Wiki Markup Open
CONF-24903 Allow macros to return an iFrame rather than just an image for the Macro Placeholder Open
CONF-24878 Naming scheme for pasted images from clipboard Open
CONF-24805 Keyboard shortcut for editing macro properties Open
CONF-24739 add templates to editor Open
CONF-24727 Editing a page: add more margin at the bottom of the editing document Open
CONF-24721 Improve Confluence's New Editor's copy and paste functionality .... Open
CONF-24653 change text style on all marked areas Open
CONF-24626 Make find & replace highlight all occurrences of search string and display a count Open
CONF-24502 Keyboard shortcuts for text alignment New
CONF-24381 Ability to extend unbalanced tables Open
CONF-24296 Make it explicit how tablular content is pasted into/as a table New
CONF-24291 Allow alignment to be inherited from existing table line when inserting new line New
CONF-24289 Inserting new lines in tables is slow on large tables (>100 rows) New
CONF-24094 Cursor should navigate 'over' items New
CONF-24026 Provide frames with editable parameters for macros as well as all special editor objects Open
CONF-23966 Shortcut for font format options Open
CONF-23454 Cannot drag and drop text in the new editor Open
CONF-23332 Pasting Confluence content in editor should copy embedded images to destination page Open

Additional Ideas

Click here to expand...

While we want the focus of this page to remain specific and detailed feedback on the new editing experience that we can address, a number of people have put considerable effort into outlining their ideas for alternate editing strategies and we also wanted to capture these below.

FromIdea
Alexy KotenkoOkay, as the WYSIWYG abilities are wider than wiki markup allows - let it be. But you can still provide a solution similar to one implemented in JIRA search. In there you have a search form for rather simple requests, and direct SQL edit for complicated requests. And if directly edited SQL is too complicated to show it as a form - it just tells you "search query is too complicated" and doesn't allow to switch back to form.

As earlier you have claimed that implementing XML-to-wiki transformation is easy - I see no problem to still allow wiki edit, but with XML format on backend and disallow wiki if something too complicated was created through WYSIWYG.

This can easily be added as a plugin, to solve your problem with complains on the core software.

Anonymous

(In reponse to Alexy)

This sounds like a very good idea, and I hope Atlassian will take the time to investigate it. By definition, people who still want to use wiki markup will not be using the most complex WYSIWYG-only formatting, so it should be possible to convert almost everything such users write back to markup.

Another suggestion would be to extend the Wiki Markup Styler plugin to do the same thing.  Ideally, any content that can be converted back to markup, would be. And any complex elements that cannot be converted would just appear as they do in the normal WYSIWYG view. This would avoid the possibility of one complex piece of content causing a whole page to be marked as "too complicated to edit through wiki markup".

If Atlassian choose to do this, the other vital requirement (for me) is that we can copy the wiki markup from the editor. At the moment, the plugin displays markup elements on-screen, but if I try to copy them it just gives me the underlying text. In common with other commenters, sometimes I prefer to copy markup from a Confluence page into a text editor and edit it there, before pasting it back (either into a different page, or into another part of the same page). 

Todd Day

Andrew Spina

Keep wiki markup format by wrapping in a "wiki markup" macro

----

Todd - Ability to wrap entire pages in the Wiki Markup macro and not have them auto-convert to storage format. Additionally:

  • Macros that come from plugins I currently use in 3.5 continue to work the same way in the wiki code block.  I'm willing to wait for the authors (Adapatvist, Customware, and the guy who wrote the LaTeX plugin) to upgrade their plugins for 4.0, but the end result must be that I can write in 4.0 wiki code blocks the same way I currently write in the 3.5 wiki editor.
  • User macros I wrote for 3.5 need to also appear in the 4.0 wiki code blocks.
  • When upgrading from 3.5 to 4.0, I want the upgrade process to wrap every page in a wiki markup block instead of converting it to the new XHTML format.
  • Site and Space themes should be definable in terms of Wiki format.
  • It would be nice if the wiki code blocks had a button on them that would convert to the new XHTML format if you pressed it.  I understand this would be a one-time no-reversal operation, and that would be fine with me.

----

Andrew

  • I haven't read through this post, but this page says to post requests here. I'm new to confluence (and like it a lot), but was wondering why wiki markup is translated into a wysiwyg format after entry. I was wondering if it made sense to allow people to make a container (like a new column) which would preserve wiki markup, but render it on the saved page as rich text? I know it's not as friendly to non-technical users, but it seems a bit closer to the middle ground. Just a thought...
Don Gamble

Treat macros and all special editor objects (images, links, etc) the same - i.e. they would all have a frame.

Currently the new editor doesn't treat everything as equivalent. This results in issues with where the insertion point moves during editing, what is selected, what gets cut or pasted, etc. Treating everything special (i.e. macros, images, links - things with parameters and/or bodies) as a framed object allows everything to be treated as an object, just like a character of text. Providing the frame also now allows you to explicitly see what is inside and outside a special object and allows you to select the object. For example, there is currently no way to select a link. You can select text that is linked, you can select an image that is linked, but you can't select a link. Raised in CONF-24026.

Don Gamble

Display the associated parameters of the object (macro, image, link, etc) as text in the header of the objects frame.

With macros and special objects now having a frame, the hidden parameters of a macro/special object can now be displayed. Entering edit mode should expose all of the hidden information that is not visible when the page is rendered. Currently entering edit mode results in still having to enter a deeper edit mode (i.e. the macro browser or the special popups) to see the true values to edit. An edit mode within an edit mode is a huge productive hit. Simply seeing how a page was created is not currently possible while in edit mode.

A guiding rule should be "While in edit mode the user will be able to inspect the page and see all the properties effecting how the page renders without needing to do any further activities." If this rule was true a majority of the productivity hit of the new editor would be resolved. To do this requires displaying the parameters of macros and special objects in their frame. Raised in CONF-24026.

Don Gamble 

Allow the parameters in the frame to be edited as name value pairs and re-interpreted when focus leaves the frame.

The final hit to productivity of the new editor is the need to enter a sub-edit mode (the macro editor or the special popups) when making a change to a parameter that is already applied to a macro or a link/image. Allowing the name value parameter pairs in the frame to be edited would allow rapid changes to be made with a few keystrokes with no loss of user focus caused by having to visit a dialog.

Allowing new parameters to be added into the frame by just typing, for example "width" which is an obvious and easily remembered parameter on many macros, would allow common edits to occur quickly. Parameters that could not be parsed after the edit completes (i.e. after focus leaves the frame) could be handled by highlighting or in a similar way to how firebugs lets users change the parameters in the html editor window. Raised in CONF-24026.

Don Gamble & Eddie Fast

The confluence editor should behave very similar to every other commonly used editor. At a high level, today's user's expectations of how an editor reacts is common across all editors. If the editor doesn't behave as commonly expected then the user's experience is compromised (some would say the editor is broken or unusable). I see these expectations as (please comment - do others agree?):

    1. The focus of all activity occurs at the insertion point or selection.
    2. Pressing backspace or delete, removes what is to the left/right of the insertion point or removes what is selected.
    3. Typing or pasting inserts the contents at the insertion point or replaces the selection and leaves the insertion point after what is selected.
    4. Moving left, right, up, down with the arrow keys or page up/down in a document, if the same key presses are reversed, should place the cursor back in exactly the same location as it was before the first key press.
    5. Holding the shift key while moving left, right, up, down should extend (or start a selection from the insertion point). Pressing the opposite key should reduce the selection.

In general, the new editor doesn't respects these user expectations. This makes it slow, hard to use, and I would argue filled with special situations that while can each be individually explained as correct - as a whole make it wrong. An editor should be a simple experience - not complex.

Specifically with respect to what should happen when the insertion point is at the beginning of a macro, i.e. just inside the body. I would suggest:

  • Pressing the backspace key should do something, currently it does nothing when just within the body.
  • Pressing the left arrow moves to the outside of the macro (CORRECT), but starting at the same spot and pressing the left arrow, while holding the shift key, doesn't appear to do anything.
    • Unfortunately, it is more complex (in Firefox at least) continuing to press the left arrow while holding shift results in first the insertion point disappearing, with nothing selected, then nothing on the next key press. After some number of key presses the insertion point reappears with no selection. Reversing, i.e. pressing the right arrow with shift held, results in the insertion point appearing, then a selection appearing, then an insertion point, etc. Nothing is obvious as you attempt to select across a macro.

Open company, no bullshit

 

A Message from Atlassian's Founders

Hi there,

Most of you already know why we removed the wiki markup editor in Confluence 4.0. We pride ourselves on being an open company, so it should be no surprise that we were really upset to learn that a few customers felt we had 'betrayed them' with this decision.

Firstly, to those people, we are genuinely sorry that you did not know about this change. We want you to know that we fully understood the enormity of this change for our existing customers - hence why we began communicating our plans over a year in advance in order to give everyone ample time to prepare. We started this process 15 months before shipping Confluence 4.0. During this period we made many public announcements about our intentions, collected tons of feedback throughout our Early Access Program, and built a comprehensive set of resources including:

  • June 2010 - At Summit 2010 we publicly announced our plans to consolidate the wiki markup and rich text editors into one single editor in Confluence 4.0
  • July 2010 - Released an FAQ about the changes we had planned. Over the year we received a lot of questions and updated the FAQ very frequently
  • December 2010 - Atlassian began using Confluence 4.0 in production internally and began gathering feedback from heavy wiki markup users
  • June 2011 - Released a comprehensive Early Access Program ("EAP") where customers could download 4.0 and provide feedback. We received and responded to over 250 pieces of feedback during the Early Access Program
  • June 2011- Included with the EAP we released a comprehensive set of "change management" documentation including:
    • A comprehensive set of release notes describing every new feature and planned change in 4.0
    • A comprehensive planning guide for Administrators, End Users and Developers
    • A quick-guide to help administrators prepare
  • June - September 2011 - Frequently updated EAP releases where we collected customer feedback and responded with changes / fixes
  • September 2011 - Released Confluence 4.0 with a microsite to help users discover new features and a complete change guide to help avid wiki markup users learn to be efficient in the new editor

If you did not hear about the new editor via all of these communiques, we're sorry. We will endeavour to communicate even more in the future, especially should there be another such major update.

Collective customer feedback drove this decision

We listen to our customers – a lot. The number one reason we made the decision to remove the wiki markup editor was the collective feedback we'd been gathering since we first released Confluence in 2004.

We've always encouraged you to publicly tell us how we can improve our products and make them work better for your organisation. We can't think of another company that is as open as Atlassian and we're proud of that.

Looking at the feedback we received and the things we heard time and time again in countless customer interviews, it was clear as day that the dual editing experience – Wiki Markup and Rich Text – was the number one hindrance to Confluence adoption.

The endless cycle of round-tripping bugs made the editor unreliable and unusable for the majority of users, and the lack of advanced features like the ability to merge table cells was stopping you from seeing the full value of Confluence.

You told us these things, we listened, and replacing wiki markup was the most viable solution to giving you what customers collectively asked for, a kick-ass editing experience with more powerful editing features.

Customers love the new editor

Has it been all bad news? No - far from it. We've been thrilled with the overall response from customers so far. Here's a sample of the feedback we've been seeing about the new editor in Confluence 4 – there's much much, much more. I didn't have time to list all of the tweets, emails and "Contact the CEO" submissions we've received:

"A recurring comment was on the WSIWYG editor used when creating pages / documents, the editor in Confluence is amazing." - Crucial Cloud Hosting Blog 

  

 

Yet... there are two sides to every story

Up front communication and listening to users aside, we're not blind to the fact that there are customers who were completely happy with the wiki markup editor and don't see the need for a change.

Don't get us wrong, we do understand their point of view. They just want a wiki markup editor and we understand their frustration at our decision to replace it with a higher fidelity storage format.

We still believe we made the best decision based on the collective feedback we received from the majority of our customers over the years – but, being completely frank, wiki markup is not coming back. The new editor is our path going forward.

We've been listening to your feedback

Thanks to all of you who took the time to provide constructive feedback about the new editor. You've helped us highlight issues that we need to address. Our Confluence team has been working really hard to get the following features and fixes into your hands:

1. Find and Replace within the editor – shipped in Confluence 4.1
2. Wiki Markup Autoformatting for Macros, Links, and Images – shipped in Confluence 4.1.2 
3. WYSIWYG Page Layouts – coming in Confluence 4.2
4. WYSIWYG Page Templates – on our short-term roadmap

We're 110% committed to making the new editor an even more kick-ass, reliable editing experience. Truly the best editing experience in the world. We've made huge leaps in the last year - but we're not done yet.

We have a team of passionate, dedicated developers working full time to improve the editor and address niggles that arise.

We're building a source editor!

We've learned from your feedback that customers have a number of valid reasons for directly editing the source of a page: 

  1. They feel locked-in - Because people were no longer able to edit a text based version of their page directly, they felt they were locked into Confluence. While you could always still get your content out via the API or through WebDAV but people wanted to be able to see it directly. This was never our intention and we're rectifying it in two ways as you will see below.
  2. They want to fix formatting niggles - Unfortunately over the years we trained everyone on this - what do you do when you hit a bug in the RTE? Switch to wiki markup. This wasn't really acceptable then and definitely isn't now, but people have asked for it over and over.
  3. Content workflows - We underestimated how many people copy the source of their page out of Confluence to work with it in other ways, whether it be updating content offline, sharing with others via email, or using a preferred text editor for things like bulk changing of link properties.

Since we realise how important source access is to you, we're currently working on a free "Advanced Editor" plugin that will allow your users to edit your page's source amongst other advanced user editing. We hope it will address the major issues that some users have identified, like the ability to search for and update URLs and the file names of embedded images.

You can check out and comment on the spec at Specification - Confluence Advanced Editor.

The beta for this plugin is now available on the plugin exchange under the name Confluence Source Editor.

We welcome your feedback - please file issues in the JIRA project at https://jira.atlassian.com/browse/SOURCE

Storage Format

Some people have questioned whether this is a vendor lock-in play. It is not. The new storage format is based on XHTML with extension tags for Confluence specific functions. We've begun documenting it here so you can see exactly what is happening under the covers - to use in your plugins, remote applications, scripts, integrations etc. I think you'll agree this is pretty "standard stuff" and able to be understood by those who need to script it.

We refer to the Confluence storage format as 'XHTML-based'. To be correct, we should call it XML, because the Confluence storage format does not comply with the XHTML definition. In particular, Confluence includes custom elements for macros and more. We're using the term 'XHTML-based' to indicate that there is a large proportion of HTML in the storage format.

Why didn't we do this in the first place?

When we shipped Confluence 4.0 we decided to not offer a source editor for a number of reasons. First of all, the new XHTML-based storage format is more complex than wiki markup so it's not as readable to the average user. Secondly, we wanted to protect less technical users from breaking their pages by accidentally deleting a closing tag or entering invalid HTML. This is why we're proposing that the source editing plugin is only enabled for your advanced users - and the storage format is not meant for day-to-day human editing.

Just try it.

Seriously, I encourage you to give the new editor a go. Listening to your feedback we've seen that many of you have not yet tried the new editor. We spent a lot of time thinking about what most people use wiki markup for - why people love it - and we determined that it was speed. Speed to be able to create content without picking up your mouse. So we've built many features and made design decisions with this in mind.

If you haven't already, please give these editor features a try:

  • Autoformatting of Wiki Markup
  • Autocomplete for Links, Media, and Macros
  • Autoconvert for Pasted Links

If you still feel that you just cannot live without wiki markup, there are many other wikis which have it as their lingua franca. We're happy to provide a list of other wiki solutions, although I assure you none are as feature rich or flexible as Confluence.

We won't stop listening

As I mentioned, we'd love your feedback on the following:

And as per the original purpose of this page, we'd love your feedback on the editor itself and how we can improve it for you. Thank you to everyone who has contributed constructively so far.

We see Confluence changing the way a company works and collaborates. That amazing change is why we come to work every day. Please help us make it a reality for you at your company.

- Mike Cannon-Brookes [Atlassian] and Scott Farquhar [Atlassian]